goodtoread.org
http://goodtoread.org/initial/d/dungeon-the/

The Dungeon

Style: Good

Attitude: Unobjectionable

In Brief: Tragic story about a man driven to revenge to the exclusion of all else; the kindness of those who look after Peony, even McLennan albeit unwittingly.

Cover of The Dungeon

Author: Lynne Reid Banks

Publisher: Collins

Published in: 2002

Age Range: Young Teens+

Period: 16th C

Setting: China / Scotland

Genres:  Historical


Characters:

  • Alan McLennan is a clan laird whose family have been murdered by a neighbouring laird and who is consumed by revenge.
  • Peony is the youngest girl of a Chinese family, bought by McLennan to be a serving girl.

Synopsis:

Alan McLennan is a clan laird, driven by revenge against the man who had his family taken away or killed in front of him. He orders the construction of a castle with a dungeon and then spends three years travelling in China as a hired mercenary to take him away from it all. In China, he buys a little girl from her family to have as a slave to look after him.

As they travel together, the two become closer but without Alan ever realising it; the kindness he once had is hidden deeply by the emotional scars of his family's murder. Eventually they return to Scotland, where the castle is ready, and the McLennan calls his men to attack the McInnes stronghold, an ill-executed plan which has tragic consequences.

Notes:

This story has just the right amount of pace in an essentially character-driven story. It's made clear to us early on that Alan is a good man who's had all his goodness swept away or buried deep by the act that took his family from him. Throughout the entire story, he is consumed by revenge, but when the moment of revenge finally arrives and the truth comes out between the two lairds, he finds himself empty.

Peony is something like eight when McLennan buys her, so about 12 when the book finishes. There's no suggestion of anything improper in the attentions of the Chinese and Scottish fighting men with whom she lives; rather, the men do their best to give her comfort especially when her own master ignores her, treating her as bought goods. One older Chinese man in particular teaches her from the wisdom of his Buddhist philosophy.

This is not a book with a happy ending. It is a tragedy in any sense of the word. McLennan's thirst for revenge blinds him to many other things, and especially to those around him. Without really meaning to, he uses the Chinese soldiers he stays with, his own people in Scotland, and Peony. Only occasionally does his former kinder self shine through, and then he denies or rejects it. Although he does take good care of Peony after his own fashion, he always disguises the fact to himself as taking good care of property rather than of a person. Right to the end, he sees her more as a good-luck charm, although this attitude clearly does nor represent the true man he could be, merely the driven man he's allowed himself to become in his quest for revenge.

“... Don't hate your master, even when he ill-treats you; pity him, for he has a young soul, and if I am not mistaken, he has suffered greatly.”

Peony tried to follow this advice. It was easy not to hate McLennan, if for only one reason — he had unbound her feet. She knew that for whatever reason, he'd saved her from a life where every step would have been an agony, and where she would have been something worse than a man's servant — a man's plaything. For this she could accept her master and absorb his changing moods and even his occasional blows, which hurt her heart more than her body. For the rest, she learned to stifle fear and not to want anything too much. She tried not to think of herself at all. Now, as 'Ma-kri-nan' strode out of the camp, she followed behind, carrying his things on her back

Saturday 26th July 2003